Formerly one of America’s most infamous prisons, Alcatraz Island may see a dramatic return to its penitentiary roots under a new proposal from President Donald Trump.
In a post on Truth Social on Sunday evening, Trump declared his intention to “rebuild and open” a “substantially enlarged” version of the historic prison to house “America’s most ruthless and violent offenders.” The president said he has directed the Department of Justice, Bureau of Prisons, FBI, and Department of Homeland Security to begin preparations for the revival of the island facility, shuttered since 1963.
“Alcatraz is a symbol of law and order,” Trump told reporters upon returning to Washington from Florida. “We used to lock up the worst of the worst and keep them far away from the public. We’re bringing that back.”
The proposal comes as part of a broader push by the Trump administration for tougher criminal justice measures. In recent months, Trump has signed executive orders advocating harsher sentencing, expanded use of the death penalty, and the reopening of overseas detention facilities, including one at Guantanamo Bay. His administration has also faced criticism over aggressive immigration enforcement, with reports of both undocumented immigrants and legal residents being deported without due process.
At a meeting with El Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele earlier this month, Trump even floated the idea of deporting U.S. citizens to El Salvador under certain conditions.
Trump said the Alcatraz plan is a response to “radicalized judges” and the legal obstacles facing mass deportations and prosecutions. “They want to have trials for every single person here illegally,” he said. “We need places to hold these people — real places, serious places.”
Alcatraz, once a military fortress and later a federal prison, gained notoriety for its harsh conditions and notorious inmates such as Al Capone and George “Machine Gun” Kelly. Operating between 1934 and 1963, the island facility was considered nearly inescapable due to its isolation and treacherous surrounding waters. It closed due to high operating costs and crumbling infrastructure.
The island, now managed by the National Park Service, draws over a million visitors annually as a historic site. Reactivating it as a prison would require major reconstruction and logistical overhauls — a prospect critics say is both impractical and politically symbolic.
Civil liberties groups have condemned the proposal, warning that it reflects a dangerous turn toward authoritarianism. Still, Trump defended the plan, calling it “a return to seriousness in how we deal with crime.”
No timeline or funding strategy has yet been released for the proposed redevelopment of Alcatraz.
